Redundancy can be a difficult subject for both employers and employees.  Usually redundancy occurs where there has been a change in the business environment and as a result an employment position is no longer required to be performed.  Whether an employment position being terminated is a redundancy or not is a question of law and includes the surrounding circumstances of the employment, workforce and the employer's business.  We recommend seeking qualified legal advice if you have a redundancy issue.

Genuine Redundancy

A genuine redundancy occurs where an employer dismisses an employee on a lawful basis due to changes in the operational requirements of an enterprise.  There are strict rules about when a dismissal can be considered a genuine redundancy.  If the redundancy is not genuine then the redundancy may be unfair dismissal of an employee.  Unfair dismissal can be a costly mistake for a business and have a detrimental impact on the terminated employee.


Our employment lawyers provide legal advice and representation to both employers and employees for employment redundancy matters. 


We can help employers determine whether a redundancy can be made in the circumstances having considered the circumstances of the business operations.  Where a redundancy has been made we can assist employers with negotiations, settlement or representation where any claim of unfair dismissal has been made.


We can help employees establish if a redundancy was lawful or not and represent employees in negotiations, settlement or unfair dismissal proceedings. 

Where Dismissal may not be a Genuine Redundancy

 A dismissal on the grounds of redundancy may not be a case of genuine redundancy where:

  • It would have been reasonable in all of the circumstances for the employer to redeploy the employee within the employer’s enterprise or a related entity.

  • The employer had a duty to consult with the employee usually because of a Modern Employment Award or Enterprise Bargaining Agreement and the employer failed to consult with the employee.

Redundancy is a challenging area of employment law.  The consideration of whether a dismissal is a genuine redundancy may take many factors into account.  Usually, an employer can make an employee redundant where the job being provided by the employee is no longer required due to reorganisation or redistribution of duties.

Factors that are often considered in redundancy include:

  • The business environment and economic circumstances

  • The performance of the business which can include past performance

  • What steps the business can take to make its operation more efficient before looking to redundancy

  • Whether the business had a duty to consult with the employee before redundancy

  • The management of the business

An employer has implied duties at law to an employee to be considerate and fair in redundancy matters.  The employer must be able to prove on the balance of probabilities that the redundancy was due to operational requirements.

In a legal crunch?

Speak to an employment lawyer today on 1800 572 417




Knowledge Centre.png
Get Your
Free Case Evaluation
Fill out the form to receive a free confidential consultation
SEE what are customers are saying about
Offices and Locations

My Legal Crunch operates in QueenslandNew South WalesVictoria and Western Australia.


Offices & Meeting Rooms

Victoria - Melbourne - Regional Areas

Melbourne | Box Hill | Docklands | Heidelberg | Mount Waverley

Pakenham | Frankston | Southbank | St Kilda | Toorak

New South Wales - Sydney - Newcastle - Regional Areas

Balmain | Blacktown | Bondi Junction | Botany | Chatswood | Hornsby | Liverpool | Miranda | Newcastle | Parramatta Pyrmont | Rockdale | Ryde | Sydney, Martin Place | Sydney, King Street | Surry Hills | Ultimo | Wollongong

Queensland - Brisbane - Gold Coast - Regional Areas

Brisbane | Bundall | Fortitude Valley | North Bank

Riverside | Southport | Surfers Paradise

Western Australia - Perth - Pilbara - Regional Areas

Perth | Osborne Park | West Perth



1800 572 417


(02) 8569 2344

Offices and Service Areas

Free Case Evaluation

Contact Us

P: 1800 572 417

F: (02) 8569 2344



  • YouTube - Grey Circle
  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Twitter Icon
  • White LinkedIn Icon
My Legal Crunch Lawyers

Disclaimer - This information has been provided for general information and education purposes only. This information is not intended and should not be taken as legal advice. This information is general in nature only and may not be applicable in all situations and may not, after the date of its presentation, even reflect the most current authority. This information should not be relied upon nor acted upon without the benefit of professional legal advice based upon your particular facts and circumstances.

© 2020 by My Legal Crunch